Frankenstein, Cinderella, Jack and the Beanstalk…..all of
these common old fairytales rely on some sort of final moral lesson. What
happens, however, when these fairytales are thrown into the cruel and
unforgiving modern times that we live in? Edward
Scissorhands performs just that complicated feat, turning a fairytale much
like the Frankenstein monster’s into a tragedy of rejection and isolation. This
isn’t much of a change from the original tales, but the combination of modern
violence and ancient moral adventure makes for a much more complex tale.
Edward’s quest into suburbia and his escape back into his mansion show the true
colors of the seemingly clean and perfect town that the Bogg’s live in.
One of the
most surprising parts of Edward’s new home and family is that other than Peg
and her children, there seems to be no moral foundation. Everyone gossips,
cheats, steals, and gangs up against those who are different. Although the
whole idea of bringing Edward into town was meant to help a lonely young boy
out, it only showed him the true terrors of the world and ended up with him
being run out. Much like Frankenstein, Edward only wants to help and do well,
but is gradually seen as more and more of a freak and more of a liability.
In almost
every fairytale, the main character has some sort of incredible talent that
makes up for their disability. The Frankenstein monster had incredible
intelligence, but was misunderstood because of his grotesque image. Edward
makes beautiful art with his hands, and at first the people of Suburbia take to
him and love what he does. As it becomes clearer and clearer however that
Edward is not anything like the rest of the people, they begin to take every
excuse they can to make him seem like a dangerous creation. He turns down the
seductress, gets used for theft, and always gets into trouble with his scissor
hands.
The moral
of the fairytale that Burton tries to base this story on is less of a moral and
more of a warning. As a troubled artist, Burton knows what it is like to feel
rejection and fake love. Although everyone loves Edward and his talent from the
start, they end up chasing him out of town. Burton tries to portray how he
feels about the industry he works in by showing that everybody only loves you
for a certain amount of time, until your talent gets old. The moral is to see
through those who will give you false hope and love only for your talent and to
stay close to those who truly love you. This is why Edward finally returns to
his home on the mountain, knowing that Kim loves him and saved him.
i really like how you connect how the older fairytales have simple moral endings and meanings behind their story but how in Scissorhands the morality is found only at the Boggs. Your idea of how Burton uses the "moral" of his fairytale not as a lesson for everyone on how we must be more morally correct, but to beware of the industry of how people aren't always the truest with how the feel about you. the way you connect how Edward returns to his hilltop home satisfied and how you must stay close to those who truly care is really clever. very well written and has alot of well thought out connections.
ReplyDeleteIsabela Vielma