Tim Burton’s film Sweeney
Todd takes the very vile, disgusting act of cannibalism and puts a very
plausible, emotional reason behind it. Viewers find themselves sympathizing
with Mrs. Lovett and Mr. Todd, all while they are slaughtering people like
cattle and serving them to others. This cannibalism is a symbol for the way
humans saw each other and treated one another in mid-nineteenth century London.
Sweeney Todd plays off the idea that it’s a “dog eat dog” (man eat man) world
out there.
The first
initial scene where Mrs. Lovett and Mr. Todd convince themselves that
cannibalism can be justified is when Sweeney kills Parelli and Mrs. Lovett
makes the suggestion that they just use the meat from the body to make pies.
They sing about their menu, and how they will “serve anyone, to anyone”. They
make commentary on the different tastes of people, how some are worse, like
lawyers, and how priests are a bit too fat. They also bring up the idea that
“those who serve will serve those up above”, meaning that society will be
flipped over and those at the bottom will rise to the top.
This is
exactly how times were in London around the mid-nineteenth century. People were
starving, the government was corrupt, creating a huge gap between the wealthy
and the poor. The average man who got miniscule pay compared to those officials
up above also heavily fueled London’s industry. This made for a very hateful
relationship between the rich and the poor. Sweeney takes this matter into his
own hands and begins eliminating the problem, one by one. Todd, however, kills
everyone, showing that the real problem in the world of man is man.
Sweeney’s
initial idea of ridding the world of man is to merely kill every last one of
them until he gets to the judge, but Mrs. Lovett takes it to the next level by
suggesting that they serve the dead to the living. This symbolizes how all the
conflict and corruption in London at that time was causing the population to
implode and eat themselves. Sweeney and Mrs. Lovett were merely helping the
cause out, by taking two wrongs and creating a right in their own mind. This is
how Burton’s film takes the most disgusting of primal human cruelties in
cannibalism and backs it up with an innocent reason.
The reason
for Todd’s carnage was obvious in the fact that he had been sentenced to hard
labor overseas for a crime he didn’t commit and had lost his beautiful wife and
child in the process. The scene that shows Barker with his perfectly happy
family is a very bright, picturesque scenario in which Benjamin has a very
optimistic, sunny view of life. Life when he returns, however, is dark, dreary,
and obviously seen through a completely different view by the newly-named Todd.
This new,
horrible view of life represents the measures that civilians in London were
pushed to at this time. Food was scarce, innocent men women and children were
being hung, and the streets were dirty with blood and corruption. This is where
mankind turns on itself and it becomes a man eat man world. Overall, Burton’s
film Sweeney Todd shows the carnage
and vileness that society pushed people to in mid-nineteenth century London.
Rosalia Esteva
ReplyDeleteI think you made an overall good analysis of the movie. Nevertheless, I disagree with you when you say Mr. Todd and Mrs. Lovett thought using the meat of the people he kills to make pies was a good thing. In my opinion neither of them could care less if they were doing good or bad, Sweeney Todd only wanted revenge and to get rid of all his evident anger and sadness, and Mrs. Lovett just wanted to make some easy money.
As I think more of it I've come to realize that it is Tim Burton that tries to justify their doings so the audience is able to relate more easily to them, even thought the characters remain careless about all the wrong they are doing.